Skip to content
Menu

Engineering guide

Magnesium, Zinc or Aluminum Anodes: How to Choose by Environment

The anode alloy is chosen by the electrolyte around the anode — soil, fresh water, brackish water, seawater or marine sediment — and then by its resistivity and temperature. This guide summarizes what ISO 15589-1:2015 and EN 12496:2013 state for each alloy, with every value traced to a clause or table.

ISO 15589-1:2015 EN 12496:2013 Every potential with its reference electrode
Organized cast sacrificial anodes on export pallets
Product visualization; the alloy for a project follows its cathodic protection design.

Quick answer

Start with the electrolyte at the anode

  • Buried in soil: magnesium or zinc, installed in backfill. For buried pipelines, zinc and magnesium alloys are the two main anode materials. (ISO 15589-1:2015, 10.2 Note, 10.3, 10.4)
  • Seawater, brackish water and marine sediment: aluminum (Al-Zn-In) or zinc. Aluminum alloys are limited to environments with a salinity above 5 g/kg, typically seawater or brackish water with a resistivity below 2 Ω·m. (EN 12496:2013, B.1.1)
  • Fresh or brackish water that needs a high driving voltage: magnesium. It is not normally required in seawater. (EN 12496:2013, B.2.1)
  • Aluminum in soil: not used in buried conditions unless the chloride content of the electrolyte is high enough. (ISO 15589-1:2015, 10.2)

Galvanic anode systems are generally considered when the current demand is low: small-diameter pipelines, short lengths of coated larger pipelines, and low-resistivity electrolytes, water, swamps or marshes. (ISO 15589-1:2015, 10.1)

Buried service

Soil: magnesium or zinc

ISO 15589-1 gives typical values in soil, measured against a saturated Cu/CuSO4 reference electrode (CSE).

ParameterZincMagnesium alloy M 1Magnesium alloy M 2
Open-circuit potential, V vs CSE-1.05 to -1.10-1.57 to -1.60-1.77 to -1.82
Closed-circuit potential, V vs CSE-1.00 to -1.05-1.52 to -1.57-1.64 to -1.69
Practical capacity, Ah/kg7801,1001,100
Practical consumption, kg/A·y11.27.57.5
Do not use above soil resistivity*50 Ω·m (5,000 Ω·cm)100 Ω·m (10,000 Ω·cm)100 Ω·m (10,000 Ω·cm)

Source: ISO 15589-1:2015, Tables 6 and 8, 10.3 and 10.4. *Even with backfill, unless an engineering evaluation or field test confirms the design requirements can be met. 1 Ω·m = 100 Ω·cm.

The protection potential for carbon steel in most soils is -0.85 V vs CSE (ISO 15589-1:2015, Table 1). Magnesium works at a much more negative closed-circuit potential than zinc, so it has more driving voltage against that criterion and can deliver current through higher-resistivity soil. The difference between the two magnesium alloys is covered in the high-potential vs standard magnesium guide.

In soil, zinc anodes shall be installed with backfill unless the soil contains chlorides or sulphates, and magnesium anodes should be installed with backfill (ISO 15589-1:2015, 10.3, 10.4). Where carbonates, bicarbonates or nitrates dominate, zinc can form passivating films that reduce its efficiency; this does not happen when the electrolyte contains sulphates or chlorides (ISO 15589-1:2015, 10.3 Note).

Marine service

Seawater and marine sediment: aluminum or zinc

EN 12496 Annex B gives typical properties at ambient temperature against an Ag/AgCl/seawater reference electrode. The capacities are practical values that already allow for self-corrosion.

Alloy (EN 12496)EnvironmentClosed-circuit potential, V vs Ag/AgCl/seawaterCapacity, Ah/kgConsumption, kg/A·y
Al-Zn-In (A 1, A 2, A 3)Seawater-1.092,5003.5
Al-Zn-In (A 1, A 2, A 3)Marine sediments-1.052,0004.4
Zinc (Z 1)Seawater-1.0378011.2
Zinc (Z 1)Marine sediment-0.9975011.8
Magnesium (M 1)Seawater-1.501,2007.3
Magnesium (M 2)Seawater-1.701,2007.3

Source: EN 12496:2013, Tables B.2, B.4 and B.6 (magnesium values for 5 °C to 25 °C).

These are typical values. EN 12496 recommends confirming the practical capacity of a specific Al-Zn-In alloy by long-term tests of at least 12 months or by long-term field experience, because short-term tests give higher figures (EN 12496:2013, B.1.2). Where DNV-RP-B401 is the design basis, its own design values are used rather than typical or test values (DNV-RP-B401 (May 2021), 3.5.2).

Zinc does not need a chloride environment and can also be used in brackish and fresh water, but its consumption of 11.2 kg/A·y against 3.5 kg/A·y for Al-Zn-In makes a zinc system heavier for the same current; EN 12496 notes this weight limitation for offshore structures (EN 12496:2013, B.3.1).

Magnesium is not normally needed in seawater because low seawater resistivity lets aluminum or zinc deliver enough current. It may be used where rapid polarisation is wanted, and is generally applicable only where frequent replacement is practicable (EN 12496:2013, B.2.1).

Operating temperature

Temperature limits

  • Zinc: generally applicable only up to 50 °C. Above that, alloys Z 1 and Z 3 can suffer intergranular corrosion, especially when buried in saline mud; above 70 °C in low-chloride environments, zinc can reverse potential with steel. (EN 12496:2013, B.3.2)
  • Aluminum: capacity falls as temperature rises. For alloys A 1 and A 2 it drops roughly linearly from 2,500 Ah/kg at 25 °C to 500 Ah/kg at 80 °C. (EN 12496:2013, B.1.2)

State the maximum operating temperature at the anode in the RFQ, so the alloy and its test basis can be agreed before production.

Checklist

Five steps before you specify

  1. Identify the electrolyte at the anode location — soil, fresh water, brackish water, seawater or marine sediment.
  2. Measure resistivity — in soil, ISO 15589-1 sets 50 Ω·m for zinc and 100 Ω·m for magnesium; aluminum needs a salinity above 5 g/kg (EN 12496).
  3. Check the temperature — zinc up to 50 °C; aluminum capacity falls with temperature.
  4. Fix the alloy and the evidence — name the composition standard, give every potential with its reference electrode, and state the test reports you expect.
  5. Let the CP design size the system — anode mass, number and spacing come from the cathodic protection design.

Questions

Short answers

Can aluminum anodes be used in soil?
Not normally. ISO 15589-1:2015 states that aluminum anodes shall not be used buried in an electrolyte unless its chloride content is high enough; zinc and magnesium are the main anode materials for buried pipelines.
What soil resistivity is too high for magnesium anodes?
ISO 15589-1:2015 advises against magnesium anodes above 100 ohm-m (10,000 ohm-cm), even with backfill, unless an engineering evaluation or field test confirms the design requirements can be met. For zinc the limit is 50 ohm-m.
Why choose aluminum rather than zinc in seawater?
Weight and temperature. EN 12496:2013 gives a typical consumption of 3.5 kg/A-y for Al-Zn-In in seawater against 11.2 kg/A-y for zinc, and zinc is generally limited to 50 degC. Zinc remains useful in brackish and fresh water because it does not need chloride.

Sources

Standards used in this guide

  • ISO 15589-1:2015 Petroleum, petrochemical and natural gas industries — Cathodic protection of pipeline systems — Part 1: On-land pipelines. Clauses 10.1 to 10.4; Table 1; Tables 6 and 8.
  • EN 12496:2013 Galvanic anodes for cathodic protection in seawater and saline mud. Annex B: B.1.1, B.1.2, B.2.1, B.3.1, B.3.2; Tables B.2, B.4 and B.6.

Values are quoted from the editions listed. Where a project specification, purchase order or CP design states other values, those govern.

Factory supply & quotation

Direct Factory Supply Across Magnesium, Zinc & Aluminum Anodes

CathPro manufactures all three galvanic anode metals in-house: ASTM B843 M1C & AZ63B magnesium anodes (bare or prepackaged), ASTM B418 Type I & cadmium-free Type II zinc ribbon and cast zinc anodes (≥ 780 Ah/kg), and DNV-RP-B401 Al-Zn-In marine anodes (≥ 2,500 Ah/kg), supplied with spark-OES heat analysis (COA) and EN 10204 3.1 certificates.

Direct engineering desk (no web form required): sales@cathprocp.com · WhatsApp +86 159 7878 1890